Getting reviews for your book is a little bit like when you first start your coaching practice and you’re trying to get testimonials. We all know they’re really important. What we don’t always realise is how difficult they are to get.
Think about it. How often have you read the reviews of anything you buy, compared to how often you leave a review? I’m guilty of reading loads of books and then quickly hitting the star rating on Goodreads. I try my absolute best to leave reviews for independently published books to help discoverability. But honestly, sometimes life just gets in the way.
So let’s talk about why reviews matter, and some practical ways to help you get them.
Why are book reviews so important?
First of all, they tell the algorithm gods that your book is worth showing to more people. They’re social proof. And particularly when your book is new, the more reviews you can generate, the better.
Yes, they will give you the warm and fuzzies — but there were four million books uploaded on Amazon last year. If you’re browsing and faced with a choice between a book with two five-star reviews and another with a thousand reviews averaging 4.5, you’re probably going to choose the second one.
Start before you publish: your launch team
A few months before publication, start thinking about who to invite to your launch team. These are your advanced readers, and you can offer them an ARC — an advanced reader copy — normally in ebook format, though you can pay for print copies if you choose to.
The ask is that in exchange for a free copy of your book before it’s published, they will do their absolute best to read it and leave an honest review on launch day. You do have to choose your words carefully here, because it’s against Amazon’s terms and conditions to require a review. But what you can do is ask really, really nicely.
You don’t need hundreds of people. Around 20 is enough to kickstart the algorithm on that first day.
Make it easy for readers to leave a review
At the back of your book, include a page that invites readers to leave a review. Here’s the ask I use in my own book, People Who Pivot — feel free to use it verbatim:
‘Before you go. Thank you for reading this book. If you enjoyed it, I’d be grateful if you can spare a few minutes to leave a brief review wherever you purchased it. Reviews are important to an author because they help bring books to the attention of readers.’
Ideally, direct people to Amazon, Goodreads, or your website. Goodreads is becoming increasingly important in the age of generative search. Generally speaking, Amazon readers tend to be slightly more forgiving than Goodreads readers, so if your star rating is a little lower there, don’t worry too much about it.
In order to have reviews on those platforms, you’ll need author profiles on both. They’re not particularly onerous to set up, and both have self-help guides to walk you through it. If you get stuck, drop me a quick email and I’ll help.
Paid services to consider
There are services that connect you with reader communities who actively seek advanced copies — bloggers, librarians, and people who love to read and write reviews. These are paid services, so factor them into your launch budget.
Netgalley is the most established, but Book Sirens is also worth looking at. Neither guarantees reviews, and they suit certain types of books more than others, so it’s worth doing your research before signing up.
Don’t forget your social platforms
Most of us as coaches are posting regularly on LinkedIn. Your followers have probably been following your writing journey, and a well-placed, warm reminder to leave a review goes a long way. It’s a wonderful way to reach people who have already read your book but simply haven’t got around to leaving their thoughts.
A few key things to remember when asking
When it comes to the ask itself, keep these in mind:
- Be specific. ‘A short Amazon review, even just a sentence, would mean the world’ is much more effective than something vague like ‘please let me know what you think.’
- Give people a direct link. Not the Amazon or Goodreads homepage — the actual page where they can leave a review. If you’ve never done it yourself, go and find it. It’s not quite as easy as you’d imagine.
- If someone tells you they loved your book — in a message, a comment, or a post — don’t just say thank you. Ask, very nicely, if they could pop those lovely words into a review. And give them the link.
- When someone leaves you a review, say thank you. Manners cost nothing. I don’t need to say anything more about that.
When the reviews aren’t what you hoped for
Eventually, you will get a bad review. Someone your book did not connect with. Someone for whom it did not resonate. Don’t take it personally. These are strangers, and they don’t know you. They don’t necessarily mean to be unkind — for whatever reason, your book just wasn’t a match for what they were looking for.
If they are mean, don’t bite back. If the feedback feels completely wide of the mark, try a reframe. Sometimes a one-star review can be so entirely misaligned with the book you wrote that it becomes marketing gold. Your three-star reviews can occasionally hold something genuinely useful. But for anything purely subjective, read it, put it down, and don’t take it too personally. If it bothers you, have a conversation with your coach about it.
And finally: lead by example
If you don’t leave reviews, how can you expect them?
Do it after reading this. Pick the last book you loved. Write one thing that was brilliant about it, one key takeaway, and who you’d recommend it to. That’s your review. Pick a platform and put it out into the world.
And then have a cup of tea and feel good about yourself.